5 Comments
User's avatar
Fr Sean Sheehy's avatar

This article, an excellent analysis of Machiavelli's propaganda that is still infecting political and religious leaders today, reminds me of the attempt by some Church leaders to separate doctrine from practice in the sense that doctrine was the ideal while practice could not be expected to meet the ideal. The problem here is that what God teaches He provides the wherewithal to accomplish.

Expand full comment
Mark terrell's avatar

When I studied government at University I was inspired by what a wonderful enterprise the whole parliamentary system is ...when I looked at it through the lends of a virtuous person and how a virtuous person could work that system for good. Alas...the system is still here but the people and their way of working it has been corrupted in so many ways that virtuous people don't stand much of a chance anymore.

Expand full comment
Derek Frew's avatar

The article assumes the economy is a zero sum game. The more I have, the less you have, but it really doesn’t work that way. Others don’t have less because Bill Gates has more. More people have more due to the economic growth he’s brought about. A rising tide lifts all boats.

Expand full comment
Derek Frew's avatar

We can be sure of one thing. Any philosophy that caters to our fallen human natures is sure to gain traction. We see it all around us today.

Expand full comment
Late but in earnest's avatar

Thankyou Katherine for another excellent analysis. It brought to mind this quote by Chesterton. The progressive creed is by nature parasitic and proclaims half-truths to turn the faithful into “hopeful half-wits”.

“Materialism says the universe is mindless; and faith says it is ruled by the highest mind. Neither will be satisfied with the new progressive creed, which declares hopefully that the universe is half-witted.”

- G. K. Chesterton, Collected Works 1920

Expand full comment