4 Comments
User's avatar
Rachmael's avatar

I ought first to have acknowledged the excellence and reassuring clarity of this article. Thank you very, very much, indeed.

Barón Mizoguchi's avatar

Really useful piece. The point I’d stress is the one on Dignitatis Humanae: its own opening says it leaves untouched the traditional teaching on the moral duty toward the true religion. So the right not to be coerced was never meant to become a duty not to propose. The Assisi section is just as good. An event isn’t a proposition, and you can only assent to a proposition. I also hadn’t thought about “proselyte” simply meaning “one who has come over”, which changes how Matthew 23:15 reads. Prudence in a place like Algeria is fair, but that’s a different argument from saying conversion isn’t the goal.

Donald Lippert's avatar

Balanced and intelligent… (Awfully lacking in much of the commentariat these days!) Thank you (and thank Mark Lambert, who is also balanced and intelligent!)

Rachmael's avatar

On one hand, our current pope, at the Grand Mosque of Algiers, identified the entity worshiped by Moslems as “the Most High” who according to his only communication to humans denies the divinity of Christ, and on the other he recites at least weekly the Gloria of the Mass which says “You alone are the Most High, Jesus Christ…” What should we think that he thinks about religious indifferentism and the Great Commission? Isn’t there a profound conflict here? Am I wrong to be scandalized?

Our Lady having expressly given her instructions at Fatima of what was needed to be done to accomplish the conversion of Russia, Leo’s predecessor went to Russia in May, 2018, to assure the prelates of the Russian Orthodox that the Catholic Church has neither an intention nor a desire to convert them. Am I wrong to be scandalized?

Our pope has also disestablished Latin as the normative language of the Church’s official texts, determining that these texts may now be officially promulgated in the vernacular languages. Not only liturgically but, now, theologically, the Church is without an internationally acknowledged common language. Anyone with a practical knowledge and experience of the treacherous world of translation must indeed fear for the coherence and integrity of Catholic teaching. Am I wrong to be scandalized?